Skip to content
Historic Florida Keys Foundation
Mission & History
Properties & Projects
Monroe County Historic Preservation Program
Key West Cemetery
Preservation Awards & Resources
Contact
Mission & History
Properties & Projects
Monroe County Historic Preservation Program
Key West Cemetery
Preservation Awards & Resources
Contact
2023
Pigeon Key Commissary and Honeymoon Cottage
Owner: Monroe County BOCC
Management: Cary Knight, Jordan Salinger & Stan Thompson
Architect: David Salay, Bender & Assoc.
Builders: Razorback, LLC
Pigeon Key Commissary and Honeymoon Cottage
Owner: Monroe County BOCC
Management: Cary Knight, Jordan Salinger & Stan Thompson
Architect: David Salay, Bender & Assoc.
Builders: Razorback, LLC
323 Fleming Street
Owner: Jamie Caballero, Key West Vacation Properties & Realty / Historic Research: Sharon Wells
609 Angela Street
Owners: Kevin & Lori Mitchell / Architect: Haven Burkee, Bender & Assoc. / Builders: Teixerira, Guerra, Piscopink & Gilly
710 Bakers Lane
Owners: Herb & Jan Smith / Architect: Matthew Stratton Builder: Jay Fairbank Construction
901 Fleming Street
Owner: Joseph Cohen / Architect: Carlos Rojas Builder: Gary the Carpenter
912 Fleming Street
Owners: Elizabeth Babaxadeh & Simon deJong / Builders: Joe Hughes, Bill Becker & Kevin Hoffman
415 Frances Street
Owner: Renay Regardie / Architect: Aileen & Antonio Osborn, A2O Architecture
1325 South Street
Owner: Bryon & Erika Hawks / Engineer: Brandon O’Flynn, Rick Milelli / Architect: Erica Poole / Builder: Mike Garcia, Conch Construction & Roofing
1107 Packer Street
Owners: Ann & George Durot / Designer: Brian Olson / Architect: William Rowan / Builder: Wade Morgan, WHM Renovations
1423 Petronia St
Owners: James Sharkey & Richard Ryan / Architect: Aileen & Antonio Osborn, A2O Architecture / Builder: McKendry Builders, Inc.
1013 South St
Owner: Frances Belzer-Reid & Gary Bixhorn / Architect: Seth Neal, T.S. Neal Architect / Builders: Mingo & Company, LLC & Denis Savoie
2022
500 Whitehead Street, Monroe County Historic Jail
Owner: Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
Management: Cary Knight & Rob Tudor
Architect: David Salay, Bender & Associates
Builders: Marino Construction & Seatech, Inc.
1218 Duval Street
Owner: 1218 Duval KW, LLC
Builder: Conch Construction & Roofing Architect: Bill Horn
522 Louisa Street
Owners: William & Linda Webb
Builder: Gary the Carpenter
533 Petronia Street
Owners: Eric Teves & Scott Buram
Architect: Matthew Stratton
Builder: Nick Egan
813 Galveston Lane
Owner: Alelia Moton-Butler
Engineer: Rick Milelli, Meridan Engineering
Builder: FMH Builders, Inc., Gulf Southern Construction Company
Organizer: Captain Jason Barroso
818 Olivia Street
Owner: William Buntain
Architect: Aileen & Antonio Osborn, A2O Architecture
Builder: Fogarty Builders
West Martello, Citadel, 1100 Atlantic Blvd.
Owner: Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
Project Management: Cary Knight & Cary Vick
Architect: David Salay, Bender & Associates
Builder: Innovative Masonry Restoration, Inc.
Crane Point Museum & Nature Center, Marathon
Owner: Florida Keys Land & Sea Trust, Inc.
Architect: Denise Watkins, RK&K Builder: All Keys Construction
1100 Grinnell Street
Owners: Gary & Susan August
Former Owner/Builders: Bob & Leslie Bell
Architect: Korth Collaborative Design
806 Southard Street
Owners: Edward & Caroline Mullin
Architect: Matthew Stratton
Builder: Liz Carpentry
1127 Von Phister Street
Owner: WTM Holdings, Inc.
Builder: Denis Savoie
Williams Hall, 729 Fleming Street
Owner: Williams Hall
Architect: David Salay, Bender & Associates
Builder: Joe Hughes
2020
1220 South Street
Owners: Dr. Frank Bervaldi & Ruby Reynolds / Architect: Michael Ingram & A20 Architecture / Builder: Toolbox, GC
826 Florida Street
Owner: Dr. Barbara Sowers / Architect: Michael Miller / Builder: J.J. Fairbank & Chuck Pratt / Design: Helen Colley & Michael Pelkey
1012 Catherine Street
Owner: Lorie Tarver / Architect: David Salay-Bender & Associates / Landscape Design: Carl Gilley
1627 Johnson Street
Owner & Architect: Michael Ingram / Builder: Holtkamp Construction / Landscape Design: Evan Bell-Ecoscapes
510 Greene Street - Old City Hall
Owner: State of Florida / Architect: David Salay-Bender & Associates / Builder: Conch Construction & Roofing / Welding: Dowling’s Welding, LLC
1307 Truman Avenue
Owner: Mathew Trahan / Builders: Kanga Construction & Mobile Shutter Service
518 Catherine Street
Owners: Patricia & David Buccello
1109 Fleming Street
Owner: Paul Murzyn / Architect: Haven Burkee-Bender & Associates / Builder: Teizeira Enterprises
938 Whitehead Street - Key West Light Station
Owner: Monroe County / Architect: David Salay-Bender & Associates / Builders: Razorback, LLC & A-1 Property Services Group, Inc.
732 Poorhouse Lane
Owners: Sharon Grayden & Stephen Bayne / Architect: Anthony D. Sarno / Builder: Bird Construction, LLC
618 William Street
Owners: MDS Holdings Florida, LLC / Architect: Haven Burkee-Bender & Associates / Builder: Kanga Construction
1408 Petronia Street
Owner: Christine Fifer / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco
415 Grinnell Street
Owner: Brad Daniel / Architect: Michael Ingram / Builder: Keystar, Inc.
1104 Elgin Lane
Owners: Janice & James Colbert
3501 S. Roosevelt Blvd. - East Martello
Owner: Monroe County / Architect: David Salay-Bender & Associates / Builders: Ruff Roofing, Specialized Property Services, Inc., Charley Toppino & Sons
2019
111-115 Whitehead St
Owner: Tracy Rupp / Engineer: Perez Engineering / Builder: Conch Construction & Roofing
321 Peacon Lane
Owner/Architect/Builder: William Rowan / Carpenter: Darryl Cooke
421-423 Simonton Street
Owner: Bud Brewer / Architect: Michael Ingram & A20 Architecture / Builder: McKendry Builders
524 Grinnell Street
Owner: Kevin Melloncamp / Builder: Kevin Melloncamp, Toolbox General Contractors
Certificate of Excellence: 525 Grinnell Street
Owners: Jon Robert Lewis & Eliza Owen Lewis / Architect: Juan C. Contin / Builder: General Construction & Engineer
616 Ashe Street
Owners: Irwin Fayne & Gary Hegedus / Builder: Falby Construction
700 Eaton Street
Owners: Michael Donner & Jessica Johnson / Architect: Michael Ingram & A20 Architecture / Builder: Bird Construction
704 Eaton Street
Owners: Todd Turner & Debra Koehler
Architect: Thomas Kelly
Builder: Steve Krieger 704 Eaton Street Owners: Todd Turner & Debra Koehler Architect: Thomas Kelly Builder: Steve Krieger
Certificate of Excellence: 713 Galveston Lane
Owners: Rusty Holland & Mary Ann Holland / Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Builder: Conch Construction & Roofing, Mike Garcia
Certificate of Excellence: 809 Eaton Street
Owners: Jon Robert Lewis & Eliza Owen Lewis Architect: Juan C. Contin Builder: General Construction & Engineer
824 Thomas Street
Owner: Gotan Hagbarth / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Builder: Dunn Construction, Chris Dunn
925 Fleming Street
Owners: Michelle Greene & Jeff Greene / Architect: Michael Ingram & A20 / Architecture / Builder: Holtkamp Construction
Certificate of Excellence: 1023 Washington Street
Owners: Donna Lindholm & Randy Lindholm / Architect: Tom Pope, P.A. / Builder: Mark D. Smith, Building Contractor, Inc.
1300 White Street
Owner: The City of Key West / Architect: Bender & Associates, Architects, P.A. / Builder: Burke Construction Group
Certificate of Excellence: 1315 Olivia Street
Owners: 1315 Olivia LLC, Ingram & Larsen / Architects: Michael Ingram & A20 / Architecture / Builder: Holtkamp Construction
2018
210 Olivia Street
Owners: Marge & Rick Holtz / Architect: David Knoll / Builder: Island Touch Construction Means Electric of Key West Carlos Plumbing Solutions Tommy’s Tile
410 Simonton Street, The William Kerr House
Owner: Marquesa Hotel / Architects: Thomas E. Pope & Gavin Scarborough / Landscape Architect: Craig Reynolds / Builder: Manley-deBoer Construction / Ironwork Artist: Reen Stanhouse
411 Bahama Street
Owner: Marquesa Hotel / Architects: Thomas E. Pope & Gavin Scarborough / Landscape Architect: Craig Reynolds / Builder: Mark Smith Construction
414 Simonton Street, The Pilot House
Owner: Marquesa Hotel / Architects: Thomas E. Pope & Gavin Scarborough / Landscape Architect: Craig Reynolds / Builder: Manley-deBoer Construction
415 United Street
Owners: James Hottmann & Kevin Winter / Architect: William Rowan / Builder: Reef Construction
506 Elizabeth Street
Owners: Carla & Jeffrey Lewis / Architect: Michael Miller Architects / Builder: Tomca Kier Construction, Inc.
916 Pohalski Avenue
Owner: Edward McGinley / Architect: A20 Architecture, LLC / Builder: Lepine Builders Harshman Painting
1010 Whitehead Street
Owners: Debra & David Speier / Builder: One Call Construction, Inc.
1117 South Street
Owners: Tina & Joe Moody / Architect/Engineer: Meridian Engineering / Builder: McKendry Builders Hansen & Bringle Perry’s Painting / Interior Designer: Leaf Modern
1233 South Street
Owners: Catherine & Glenn Anderson / Engineer: Jim Reynolds, P.E. / Designer/Builder: Catherine & Glenn Anderson Premier Painting of Key West
701 Passover Lane, Sexton’s House
Owner: City of Key West / Architect: Michael Miller Architects / City Engineer: Kreed Howell / Builder: Pedro Falcone Contractors, Inc.
533 Eaton Street, The Studios of Key West
Owners: The Studios of Key West / Architect: Michael Miller Architects / Builder: D.L. Porter, Inc.
2017
112 Hutchinson Lane
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owners: Bruce & Barbie Cook / Architect: Will Shepler / Builders: Island Touch Construction, Castro Construction
307 Truman
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owners: Scot & Heather Korth / Architect: Korth Collaborative Design / Builder: Tomca Kier Construction
320 Grinnell - Lucy’s Retired Surfers’ Bar & Restaurant
Certificate of Excellence
Architect: Carlos O. Rojas / Builder: Brian Botsford / Painter: Lazaro Vento
504 Angela - Aqua Side Bar
Certificate of Excellence
Owners: Michael & Kimball Ingram / Architect: Michael B. Ingram / Builder: McKendry Builders, Inc.
525 Olivia
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owner: Robert Cerkleski / Architect: Perez Engineering, Brandon O’Flynn / Builder: Mike Garcia & Conch Construction
626 Grinnell
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owners: Christopher Belland & Piper Smith
712 Love Lane
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owners: Andrew Fleming & Gary Shepherd / Architect: Guillermo A. Orozco / Builder: Barracuda Builders
845 Galveston Lane
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owners: Diane Kunze & Arthur Brown / Architect: Michael B. Ingram / Builder: McKendry Builders, Inc.
921 Truman - 7 Fish Restaurant
Certificate of Excellence
Owners: Bob & Noreen Pollman / Architect: William P. Horn / Builder: Burke Construction
923 Angela
Certificate of Excellence & A Star
Owners: Gary & Joelle Volenec
1001 James Street - Keys Energy Building
Certificate of Excellence & A Star:
Owner: Keys Energy Services / Architect: Bender & Associates Architects / Builder: Biltmore Construction
2016
623 Angela Street
Owner: Dr. John Calleja / Architect: David Salay, Bender & Associates / Builder: Holtkamp Construction
620 Ashe Street
Owners: Tom & Deborah Jackson / Architect: Rob Delaune / Builder: Rick Bird, Bird Construction
598-601 Bonito Avenue
Owners: Margaret Matheson & Dylan Hardy Matheson, Patricia Adams McNaughton
1421 Duncan Street
Owners: Carla Agostini & Robin Gay / Architect: Bender & Associates / Builder: Chris Dunn, Dunn General Contractors / Millwork: Steve Bringle, Hansen & Bringle Cabinet & Millwork / Landscape Designer: Carl Gilley
1019 Eaton Street
Owner: Glenn Kingsbury / Architect: Tom Pope / Builder: Lee Mattingly, Mattingly Construction
1417 Eliza Street
Owners: Angela & Terry Wright / Architect: David Salay, Bender & Associates / Builder: Brian Wofsey, Barracuda Builders, Inc. / Landscaper: Jonathan Jelen, Zenscapes
5 Higgs Lane
Owners: Judy & David Descoteau / Architect & Builder: Kevin Melloncamp, Toolbox GC
617 Grinnell Street
Owner: Martin Higgins & Karen Schultz / Architect: William Rowan / Builder: Mark Mayer, Florida Keys Construction
527 Margaret Street
Owners: Kirk Thompson & Brett Burch / Architect: William Shepler / Builder: Paul Misch/John Tutlewski, PPK, LLC / Designer: Dale Trice, Design Services of Florida
825 Southard Street
Owner: Glenn Kingsbury / Architect: Tom Pope / Builder: Chris Fogarty, Fogarty Builders
1012 Southard Street
Owners: Deborah & William Romano / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Engineer: Perez Engineering / Builder: Robert Reilly, Bird Construction
1008 Watson Street
Owners: Michael Dutzer & Rob Mansman / Architect: Michael Ingram / Builder: Brendan Milligan, Superintendent for Fairbanks Construction
2015
1222 Grinnell Street
Owners: Patricia & Chester Hauck / Architect: Perez Engineering / Builder: Conch Construction & Roofing Certificate of Excellence
704 White Street, Casa Contenta
Owners: Norm & Sue Fowler / Builder/Carpenter: Suncoast Construction Certificate of Excellence
617 Freeschool Alley
Owner: Johnathan Ingham / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Builder: Holtcamp Construction Ceramic Star
625 Margaret Street
Owners: Henrik Holback & Claus Jensen / Architect: Haven Burkee, Bender & Associates / Builder: Toolbox, Inc. General Contractors Ceramic Star
816 Eaton Street
Owners: Steve & Janice Dickson / Architect: K2M Design, Inc. / Builder: Fairbanks Construction / Ceramic Star
530 Catherine Street
Owners/Builders: Todd Kemp & Brian Boyer / Engineer: Meridian Engineering / Ceramic Star
421 Virginia Street
Owners/Builders: Todd Kemp & Brian Boyer / Ceramic Star
412 Grinnell Street
Owners: Lawrence & Colleen Halverson / Architect: Matthew Stratton / Builder: Roger Townsend Ceramic Star
401 Duval Street • Saint Paul’s Episcopal Church
Owner: Father Larry / Architect: Carlos Rojas / Builder: All Keys Construction / Ceramic Star
300 Whitehead Street, Truman Gate
Owner: Tampoa / Architect: Carlos Rojas / Builder: J.C. Ceramic Star
616 Simonton Street • Old Town Key West Fire House
Owner: City of Key West / Architect: K2M Design, Inc. / Builder: D.L. Porter Ceramic Star
2014
325 Julia Street
Owners: Julie Fondriest & Christina Grass / Designer: Julie Fondriest / Builder: Joel DeSantos, JDS Construction
409 Grinnell Street
Owners: Louis & Julie Battaglia / Architect: Carlos Rojas Master Craftsman: Alex Shalimov
The San Carlos Institute, 516 Duval Street
Architects: Margaritta & George Kavly & Raul Rodriguez / Builder: Florida Le Mark Construction, Miami
907 Catherine Street
Owner: George F. Gudat / Architect: Richard Meletti, Meridian Engineering / Builder: Brian McKendry
912 Packer Street
Owner/Builder: Michael Garcia
924 Flagler Avenue
Owner: Tim Reimer / Architect: Bender & Associates, David Salay / Builder: Holtkamp Construction, Gerald Killion
1021 Fleming Street, The Mariner’s Cottage
Owner: Deborah E. Lippi / Architect: Robert Delaune Builder & Master / Craftsman: Brenton Teixeira
1306 Laird Street
Owners: Carol & Jeff Burnham / Architect: David Knoll / Builder: Holtkamp Construction, Steve Rupp
1406 Olivia Street
Owners: Joseph & Tina Moody / Architect: Peter Pike / Builder: Mingo & Company
2013
3131 Margaret Street
Owner: Scott Saunders/Fury Management, Inc. / Architect: Michael Ingram & Anthony Sarno of mBi-k2m / Builder: Ales Bursa, Skylimit Construction
426 Elizabeth Street
Owners: Jeff & Julie Cornfeld / Architects: Bert Bender & David Salay / Builder: JARCON Construction / Interior Design: David Smith / Landscape Architect: Craig Reynolds
618 Grinnell Street
Owner: Christopher B. Mario / Architect: The Lineberry Architectural Group / Builder: Toolbox General Contractors
817 Waddell Avenue
Owner: Henry Holliday / Architect: Thomas E. Pope / Builder: Mark D. Smith Building Contractors
1016 James Street
Owners: Jim & Maria Koch / Architect: Michael Miller / Builder: Mark Mayer, Florida Keys Construction
1227 Von Phister
Owners: Lee Sider & Greg Stanton / Architect: Michael Miller / Landscaping: Scott Montgomery of Native Landscaping
The Newman Methodist Church
Pastor: Beverly Green / Project Managers: Donald Carey & Rudy Rivas / Architect: Michael Miller / Builder: Mark Mayer, Florida Keys Construction
2012
319 Amelia Street
Homeowners: Dave & Maria Bootle / Architect: Tom Pope / Builder: Rick Bird
607-609 Ashe Street
Homeowners: The Studios of Key West / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Builder: Affiliated Construction / Interior Design: JANGEORGe / Landscaping: Native Landscaping & Brian Roy Landscaping
1901 Flagler Avenue
Homeowners: David Pouliot & Oksana Davyd / Architect: William Rowan / Builder: One Call Construction
530 Grinnell Street
Homeowners: Bobby & Natalie Brooks / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Builder: Holtkamp Construction / Landscaping: Patrick Tierney
1210 Washington Street (before)
Homeowners: Jan & Barrett Clisby / Architect: Rob Delaune / Builder: Mark D. Smith Building Contractor, Inc.
1210 Washington Street
Homeowners: Jan & Barrett Clisby / Architect: Rob Delaune / Builder: Mark D. Smith Building Contractor, Inc.
1517 Washington Street
Homeowners: Guillermo Orozco & Kent Ducote / Residential Designer: Guillermo Orozco / Builder: Toolbox Construction / Landscaping: Patrick Tierney
Fort Zachary Taylor
Owner: State of Florida / Architect: Bender & Associates / Builders: Contracting Specialists Inc. / Engineer: Atlantic Engineering / Roofing: Florida Keys Waterproofing Inc.
2011
517 Grinnell
Owners: Mr. Rudy Molinet & Mr. Harry Hoehn / Project Manager: Rudy Molinet / Designer: Harry Hoehn / Architect: Michael Miller / Contractor: Sky Limit Construction
1317 Grinnell
Owners: Ms. Bonnie Picou & Mr. Paul Dietz / Architect: Thomas Kelly / Contractor: Roger Townsend
711 Elizabeth St.
Owner: Ron de la Pena / Contractor: Kevin Mellencamp, Toolbox
819 Elizabeth
Owners & Builder: M. Darene Cahill & Mr. John Martini / Architect: Michael Miller
715 Ashe St.
Owner & Designer: Elizabeth Smith / Architect: Tom Pope / Builder: Chris Fogarty/Fogarty Builders Foreman & Project / Manager: Peter Marshall
702 Whitehead St., Cornish AME - Before
Leadership & / Inspiration: The late Paster James Thornton & Assistant Paster Charles Majors
702 Whitehead St.,Cornish AME - After
Contractor: John Mann of All Keys Construction / Architect: Michael Miller
922 Catherine St.
Owners: Ms. Susanne & Mr. Oliver Landis / Architect: Mr.Tom Pope / General Contractor: Karl Walters, KAWA / Project Foreman: Gunther Fojuth & Larry Carlson, Master Craftsman